13

Retro gaming consoles are on-topic, so it makes sense that retro games should be too.

In proposal some people voted against games though, so I'm asking to make sure we agree.

15

Questions about game play are likely off-topic, I feel. There is a huge gamer community online to draw on that is about gaming specifically, not necessarily in a retro manner.

Even Wikipedia refers to the ancient gamer stuff that is easily available as "game cruft", as it is very abundant (and nearly impossible to verify, sometimes.)

So, questions related only to game play probably already have a home out there. A question about getting a system, emulated or not, working so a game can be launched is probably on-topic.

For example, I consider getting Wumpus working on some emulators sort of an acid test.

  • I would say that getting games to run is on topic for example this Ultima I question leads to a discussion about 6502 vs 65C02 instructions. Likewise there are plenty of games that run on a ROM01 IIgs but not a ROM03 IIgs, or require a specific Amiga Kickstart ROM version – Michael Shopsin May 3 '16 at 14:04
  • I've already commented on this question, and have the same reservations as this answer. – user12 May 3 '16 at 14:30
7

Games from the past in itself are likely too broad a topic and would water the focus of this site too much. What I mean are questions like "How do I perform special move X in game Y", "How do I get endless lives in game A", "Was game B the first of its kind or were there similar games before" or something like that, which do not at all or only peripherally touch on the technical details of the particular retro platforms. Those are likely better asked on https://gaming.stackexchange.com/.

What is fine, in my opinion, is using them as examples to make the problem more concrete, like in the questions Did any Amiga 500 games or programs (apart from paint programs) use more than 32 colours?, Is there way to save the save state? or GameBoy Color games do not save any more.

The focus in those questions is clearly the methodology used on the platform, not the actual games in particular.

However, if the question to a particular game of the past doesn't fit into https://gaming.stackexchange.com/ at all, then it might be fine to ask it here. I guess that depends on the question on a case by case basis.

  • I had the same concern about history, but that is apparently on-topic. – Nick Westgate Apr 23 '16 at 21:57
7

The tricky part with your test case is that it's not obvious from the question whether you're asking how to play the game or how to get it to work on the specific retro system in question. It's especially tricky because it wouldn't necessarily be obvious to the person asking the question, either. If they had access to multiple systems, and posted "it works on my ][+ but not on my //e", that would be a very strong signal that there's an issue with the platform itself.

I think the biggest problem with the question is the subject, "How do I become a Space Ace in Ultima I?", which sets the tone for the reviewer. Unless I'm aware of the coding flaw in Ultima I my assumption will be that you're asking about game play, and assuming that PEBKAC.

If your subject and question had the tone, "I'm doing things that should work, but they're behaving incorrectly on my //e", that sends a message to the reader that you're looking for help diagnosing strange behavior, rather than seeking to learn how to become a Space Ace.

I dislike the idea of rejecting valid questions because the asker didn't have enough experience to frame the question well, but until the asker has enough knowledge of the situation to identify that something retro-platform-specific is at fault, they shouldn't really be asking gaming questions here.

  • @fadden: I agree with your analysis, though I didn't think about it this much and simply presented a question (when requested) that I'd seen asked in the Facebook Apple II Enthusiasts group that could only be answered by a retro-savvy community. A simpler case would be just asking a question about a game on a niche retro platform which is unlikely to be answered in Arqade because the platform users are here, not there. In any case, I'll accept the highest voted answer and think it's a shame such questions will be off-topic. – Nick Westgate Apr 25 '16 at 23:12

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .